I have been using a webpage (Be Imba!) to assess PvE gear sets. Now that the armory has updated to reflect the new changes with the latest patch I have tabulated our guild (and those that run with us often).
**Note this is just for Gear/Enchant info only, not a reflection of player skills. For raid evaluation only!!!**
Golfagus 230.93
Skarjj 223.92
Guryon 220.45
Huntersblade 216.13
Sorengal 207.19
Cattibree 204.93
Thayvian 204.87
Solundra 203.41
Catibree 194.82
Bovinoir 141.95
Morbidisha 137.91
Greylorn 137.48
Eleena 190.66
Sythis 180.81
Joberman 157.01
Wuntufbadaz 133.69
Senerian 126.27
What this will reflect is how the pve gear drops from kara and heroic dungeons actually do make an impact in these dungeons. PvP gear may give you things like more crit%, higher spell damage, etc, but there are intangibles that make you/us more successful in a Raid scenario. So don't let the pure single stat boost in pvp gear sway you. The PvE gear does have its value.
Does this mean we can't be successful when we have scores below 180? No it does not, but it does show the need to get the right gear for the right situation. Remember the difficulty we had against Shade of Aran? Higher scores in this field across the board makes an impact!
If you'd like to monitor these scores yourself head to:
http://be.imba.hu/Remember to create a free account here and LOGIN so that you can use [ Force Armory Update ] option to get the latest correct numbers. Also if you logged out last with your pvp set on, it'll reflect that. Login and swap to your PvE set and check the site again later.